Many years ago, when I was running west coast operations for a telecommunications company, my office manger approached me with a problem. “There’s a gentleman out here who’s perfect for the in-house tech job, but he’s handed me these sheets for his W-4.” I looked at the sheets and realized that they were (what I now know as) typical tax protester stuff, claiming he wasn’t a citizen of the United States but a citizen of California, and thus exempt from US taxes. My office manger continued, “He refuses to fill out the W-4.”
That company had a policy that until all the employment paperwork had been completed, an employee couldn’t start working. I went to the potential new hire and told him, after introducing myself, “You can either fill out a W-4 or we’ll find someone else.” He protested, and I cut him off, telling him that we were a business and didn’t have time for tax shenanigans. He left and we found someone else.
Today the Tax Court looked at the case of a tax protestor. He submitted similar documentation in his job as a car salesman. He filled in his tax return for two years with all zeroes. The IRS didn’t find this as humorous as you and I would. Neither did the Tax Court. After admonishing the protestor for the error of his ways (and warning that he faced a penalty if he advanced the same groundless arguments in the future), the Court found for the IRS.
You can find the Tax Protestor FAQ here.